India's Daughter exposes the naivity of "Indian culture". And no wonder, it was banned from airing in India by proponents of the same.
The documentary describes the gang rape of Jyoti Singh (Nirbhaya) in excruciating details. Then focuses on how Mukesh Kumar (one of the rapists) and the defence lawyers (for the rapists) defend the act. The protests are covered and so are the issues in unreasonably demanding/issuing death penalty.
I've seen it and it is a stable portrayal of the situation. There was no reason to ban it, and any defence that the Government of India makes are lame excuses.
These excuses might seem necessary because the truth is that rapists are not a special species of people, but members of the society who are waiting for their chance. It makes the word "Indian culture" (of looking down on women) sound really bad.
India's Daughter - A documentary by Leslee Udwin about December 16 gang rape and murder of Jyoti Singh in Delhi. It documents the attitude of the guilty, their guilty lawyers, victim's friends and relatives, the public, and the judiciary. Some horrifying defences by the lawyers of the guilty - like "A woman is a flower, she should be protected, a man is like thorn, strong and tough.", and so many more worse things. Read the controversies surrounding it here
It was banned in India.
The reason is that the guilty are shown defending themselves. And as usual, the Indian people thought for Indian people and decided that it is too sensitive for Indian people to listen to the guilties' twisted and crooked logic of justifying rape.
Parliament of India used the grounds that the interviews in Tihar jail were not made with the agreement that the videos could be used for commerical purposes. This is just a lame excuse.
I conceive who gave the permission but the reality is what the man spoke reflects views of many men in India. Why we are shying about it? We are not confronting the issues. Suggesting death penalty is not the answer. We have to confront the issue that many men in India do not respect women. Every time a rape happens, the victim is blamed to have provoked the men. Let’s be aware of the view and not pretend all is well
The Hindu writes in its editorial how banning is not the solution and why documentaries like these need to be made to expose the culture of tolerance towards gender violence.
Kavita Krishnan who appears in the documentary has written a nuanced piece about it here: Nirbhaya film: Solidarity is what we want, not a civilising mission
Rukmini Shrinivasan writes about how India desperately need an insight into how rapists think: Wishing away India's culture of rape. Excerpt
If India had read the minds of its rapists and molesters correctly, and had acknowledged that women's freedoms are what offend these criminals and their defenders, there would have been no need for an "India's Daughter." Unfortunately, it is only when interviews of this nature are conducted that we will ever know how many men in India still think of women. The least we can do is act honestly and immediately on these repugnant attitudes.
Report broken links, send more links. Free speech, ftw!
If you're in UK you can watch it on BBC's website till 10th March
Video sharing sites
Youtube is pulling down links due to court order
- Link 1 Description:
This is the documentary that has been unethically banned in India. It sheds a new light on complex socioeconomic and cultural state of India that determines the status of India's women in their society. On one hand, there is an increased awareness and new zeal to fight horrible crimes on women and on the other hand, the people with twisted and misguided ideas still cause harm to women in India.
- Link 2
- Link 3
- Link 4
- Link 5
- Link 6